The 2021 Brunello ranks among Montalcino’s most successful vintages. A classic year with great potential that expresses the character of Sangiovese (Grosso) in its elegant, vibrant, and fragrant form. A paradigm shift: less power, more finesse. Photo: Shelby Knick

The idyllic town of Montalcino sits at an elevation of about 564 meters above the UNESCO-protected landscape of the Val d’Orcia and is synonymous with diversity: varying elevations, exposures, and soil types give rise to a broad stylistic spectrum. Photo: Consorzio Brunello di Montalcino

Brunello di Montalcino 2021 – Precision, Excitement, and Classic Character

Giuseppe Lauria, December 2025

The 2021 Brunello ranks among Montalcino’s most successful vintages. It combines classic style with remarkable precision, freshness, and clarity, impressively expressing the character of Sangiovese (Grosso) in its transparent, vibrant, and fragrant form.

Climatically, the year was generally balanced. A comparatively cool spring, marked by a significant frost event on April 8, slightly delayed the start of the growing season. This was followed by a warm, yet rarely extreme, and generally dry summer. Welcome rainfall at the end of July and again at the end of August supported the vines and promoted even ripening . The frost primarily affected the lower-lying vineyards and led to harvest losses of up to 30% in some areas . The partially reduced yields had an additional positive effect on quality.

Particularly influential was the pronounced day-night temperature range during the ripening phase, which favored a slow and nuanced development of aromas while preserving the freshness and acidity typical of the grape variety. The harvest took place largely under ideal conditions, with healthy grapes and excellent phenolic ripeness.

In the glass, the 2021 Brunello appears clear, with a rather linear profile, focused, and profound. As is so often the case with Sangiovese, the aroma is dominated by red cherry, sour cherry, and raspberry, complemented by floral and spicy notes, Mediterranean herbs, delicate spices, and a cool, mineral component. The fruit comes across as precise and transparent, rarely overripe or jammy.

Here and there, there are also wines that still seem somewhat masked by the wood or appear over-extracted. But the trend in Montalcino is quite clear: the wines are once again more terroir-driven and have become more elegant and precise over the years.

The Benvenuto Brunello tasting is traditionally held at the Sant’Agostino Monastery Museum in Montalcino and is reserved for an international audience of industry professionals.

Stylistically, the 2021 Brunello vintage is closer to “classic” vintages—which emphasize elegance, balance, and longevity—than to powerful or opulent styles. Compared to 2020, it appears less ripe and fruity, but instead more focused, taut, and tightly structured, with freshness, varietal Sangiovese aromas, and pronounced verticality.

It is precisely this tension and precision that suggest a high aging potential. Bernardino Sani, CEO and oenologist at Argiano, confirms this assessment: “I agree—this vintage reminds me of 2013, but also of a blend of the power of the 2019 vintage and the great finesse of the 2016 vintage.”

Almost unanimously, people speak of a “classic year”—albeit a modern one—that can no longer be viewed through the lens of the 1970s and 1980s. Leonardo Berti, chief oenologist at Poggio di Sotto, concurs: “2021 was a classic vintage—or rather, a new classic. Without extreme temperatures, with well-distributed rainfall, but with a harvest 15 to 20 days earlier than in the 1970s and 1980s.”

Francesco Ripaccioli of Canalicchio di Sopra, located in the northern part of the appellation with cooler influences and mineral-rich soils, sums it up this way: “A lively, exciting wine—sunny, vertical, and yet round—that surprises with its energy and depth and gives the terroirs room to clearly express their own character.”

Paolo Bianchini, owner of Ciacci Piccolomini d’Aragona, sees parallels with the 1997 vintage, which was highly acclaimed at the time. Among Italian wine experts, the 2021 vintage is often placed in the same category as cooler years such as 2018, 2014, and, in some cases, 2008.

For me, however, 2021 has significantly more smoothness and depth; the tannin structure is also of higher quality and more refined, especially compared to the very lean and crisp 2018 vintage and the less precise 2014. Overall, I rate the 2021 vintage significantly higher.

On the palate, this vintage is vertical and exciting, with good density and structure, but without excessive concentration. The tannins are present, fine-grained, and precisely integrated, while a lively, well-balanced acidity supports the structure and lends freshness and definition to the carefully crafted fruit. Despite their structure, many 2021 Brunellos should be approachable even in their youth, without losing any depth or seriousness.

Conclusion: The 2021 Brunello di Montalcino proves to be a surprisingly vertical, exciting vintage with refined, clearly defined character. The fruit is perfectly ripe, supported by a precise, rather cool bouquet and the typical spice of Sangiovese. Drinkability and internal tension combine convincingly with depth and structural substance.

Many wines are likely to reach their initial drinking window in just a few years, without losing any of their aging potential. The vintage appeals equally to lovers of classic Brunello styles and discerning collectors.

The producers in Montalcino have succeeded in crafting structured wines whose acidity is present yet never overpowering. It is precisely balanced, maintaining a remarkable equilibrium between body, extract, and concentration. In the cellar, the winemakers resisted the temptation to over-extract the wines—as was often the case in the 2000s. This is a welcome shift in approach, demonstrating that the realization has taken hold that, in this context, less is more.

These are wines that meet two important market needs: on the one hand, they appeal to a broad audience—not least the American market, which remains the most important and tends to seek intensity and power. And at the same time, they appeal to the more classically oriented purists who prefer interpretations that are closer to the terroir. From this perspective, Brunello demonstrates a remarkable, continuous evolution.

The extensive work carried out as part of “Benvenuto Brunello” is now clearly bearing fruit.

The new president of the Consorzio del Vino Brunello di Montalcino is Giacomo Bartolommei, the youngest president in the consortium's history, who took office in June 2025 at the age of 33.

The Benvenuto Brunello 2025 offered a focused, nuanced look at the current vintages from Montalcino and once again confirmed the appellation’s stylistic diversity.

Outstanding Entry-Level Brunello 2021 (Annata)

Argiano · Canalicchio di Sopra · Capanna · Caparzo · Caprili · Castello di Romitorio · Ciacci Piccolomini · Cortonesi · Col d’Orcia · Fanti · Fuligni · Gianni Brunelli – Le Chiuse di Sotto · Gorelli · Lisini · Loacker · Preto (Giodo) · Pietroso · Poggio di Sotto · Salicutti · Salvioni · San Polino · Ucceliera · Talenti


Outstanding Single-Vineyard and Selection Wines 2021

AD 1441 (Castello Tricerchi) · A Diletta (Col di Lamo) · Filo di Seta (Castello di Romitorio) · Vigna Marrucheto (Banfi) · Fior di Meliloto & Fior del Vento (Corte Pavone) · Giodo · La Pieve (La Gerla) · Nicco (Capanna) · Paesaggio Inatteso (Camigliano) · Piaggione & Sorgente (Salicutti) · Vigna La Casaccia & Vigna Montosoli (Canalicchio di Sopra) · Vigna del Suolo (Argiano) · Vigna Pianrosso (Ciacci Piccolomini) · Vallocchio (Fanti) · Vignavecchia (San Polo) · Piero (Talenti) · Rennina (Pieve Santa Restituta - Gaja) · Sugarille (Pieve Santa Restituta - Gaja)